8 Goalkeepers Who Could Replace André Onana at Manchester United
Manchester United are preparing for a massive summer overhaul, and one of the key areas demanding attention is the goalkeeping department. While André Onana arrived with high expectations following his move from Inter Milan in 2023, his performances have been a mixed bag, marred by high-profile mistakes and shaky form.
As the Red Devils eye a new era under fresh leadership, let’s explore eight potential goalkeeper signings who could replace Onana at Old Trafford.
1. David de Gea (Fiorentina)
The return of a legend? De Gea, who left Manchester United after 12 seasons, has reignited his career with Fiorentina. With 7 clean sheets in Serie A and strong performances in Europe, he’s proven he’s far from finished. The Spaniard may even consider a return to Old Trafford now that Erik ten Hag and John Murtough are no longer at the club.
2. Juan Musso (Atalanta/Atlético Madrid)
Currently on loan at Atlético Madrid, Musso is struggling for minutes behind Jan Oblak but remains one of Europe’s top shot-stoppers. His elite save percentage and sharp reflexes could make him a perfect short-term solution for United’s goalkeeping crisis.
3. Mike Maignan (AC Milan)
If United are looking for a top-tier option, Mike Maignan could be the dream signing. The French international boasts 55 clean sheets in 148 games for Milan and was pivotal in their 2021/22 Serie A title win. He brings leadership, consistency, and world-class shot-stopping ability.
4. Illan Meslier (Leeds United)
Still just 24, Meslier is already a Championship veteran with over 240 appearances for Leeds. While talented, his inconsistency is a concern. Yet, with the right coaching, he could develop into a dependable long-term option for United.
5. James Trafford (Burnley)
One of England’s brightest young keepers, Trafford has kept an astonishing 24 clean sheets in 33 games. Linked with Newcastle last summer, he’s proven himself at Burnley and could be a steal for United if they act fast.
6. Senne Lammens (Royal Antwerp)
A wildcard option, 22-year-old Lammens has impressed in Belgium and is on United’s radar. The Antwerp No. 1 has already expressed admiration for the Red Devils and wouldn’t say no if they came calling. A future investment with sky-high potential.
7. Gregor Kobel (Borussia Dortmund)
Dortmund’s No. 1 has quietly become one of Europe’s most reliable keepers. With 49 clean sheets in 149 matches and strong distribution skills, Kobel would bring calmness and authority to United’s backline. Chelsea are also interested, so competition will be fierce.
8. Altay Bayındır (Manchester United)
Already at the club, Bayındır could be the surprise solution. His standout FA Cup showing against Arsenal turned heads, and with Onana faltering, he may yet earn a shot as United’s No. 1 before the season ends.
Final Thoughts
Manchester United are at a crossroads with their goalkeeping situation. Whether they go for a proven name like Maignan or give Bayındır his chance, it’s clear that a reliable shot-stopper is essential if the club wants to return to the top of English and European football.